Perhaps the boldest and more than daring satire of its date, Ernst Lubitsch’s Are or otherwise not is put brand new stage to own eg audacious clips to follow because Stanley Kubrick’s Dr. The story out of Is or not as existed into in the radio changes and additionally one to from the Screen Guild Theatre transmitted into Powell and you will Diana Lewis; an effective German stage type because of the Juergen Hoffmann produced in 1988; a Bollywood motion picture type, Maan Gaye Mughal-e-Azam, released from inside the 2008; a defectively gotten Broadway development staged from inside the 2008; and yet an alternate stage variation when you look at the Budapest, Hungary, last year. The essential detailed of their reincarnations, however, is a beneficial 1983 movie remake under the same term that have Mel Brooks replacing his or her own kind of zany jokes and you may casting themselves and spouse Anne Bancroft regarding Benny/Lombard opportunities beneath the direction from Alan Johnson. It’s a special sprightly, fun motion picture, which have Bancroft in particular offering a beneficial scintillating abilities – but nevertheless not quite in identical class as the Lubitsch version. Tv tests and you will Dvd launches (including a beneficial Requirement Range variation released inside ) has greeting contemporary watchers to comprehend the original film without any figurative cries regarding “Too early!” unleashed from the watchers and you will critics of its big date. By the Roger Fristoe
目次
Whenever Benny explained it absolutely was satire and coaxed your back in to see the remaining film, the guy appreciated it and wound-up enjoying they 46 times!
Screenwriter Samson Raphaelson, Lubitsch’s collaborator into the such as for example screenplays given that Merry Widow (1934) and Research rates brand new Part (1940), declined to type because of it project. The guy afterwards said that “I did not get it within the us to make gags concerning Nazis inside 1941.”
Into kysymyksiГ¤ avoimista suhteista the a world in which Shine gravestones is actually missing because of the Italian language bombing, one of many stones holds title regarding “Benjamin Kubelsky,” which was Jack Benny’s beginning name.
When Benny’s father went to understand the flick, he was outraged observe their child within the a beneficial Nazi consistent and stormed outside of the theater.
Benny provided to let Carole Lombard has actually best charging once she mentioned in order to your you to definitely, anyway, “You already have all the lines.”
Lombard was happier to-be dealing with good looking more youthful leading man Robert Stack, have been a buddy since he had been a keen awkward adolescent.
Sig Ruman – just who performs Ehrhardt and is constantly calling for their adjutant, Sergeant Schultz – takes on a characteristics named Sgt. Schultz inside the Billy Wilder’s Stalag 17 (1953).
Benny afterwards asserted that within his whole flick profession he previously appreciated merely about three out of his clips – along with “loved” only one: Are or otherwise not getting .
Col. Ehrhardt: “I watched him to your phase whenever i was a student in Warsaw immediately following through to the conflict. What he did so you can Shakespeare the audience is starting now to Poland.”
Maria: “Remember myself getting flogged regarding the darkness, screaming; abruptly brand new lighting go right ahead and the audience finds out me personally toward the floor within stunning dress!”
Maria: “Lieutenant, this is actually the first time I have ever before met one exactly who could shed about three tons of dynamite in two minutes.”
Strangelove (1964), Mel Brooks’ The brand new Manufacturers (1967) and you may Quentin Tarantino’s Inglourious Basterds (2009)
Siletsky: “They call your Amount Camp Ehrhardt.” Joseph (disguised as Col. Ehrhardt): ” Ha ha. Yes, sure. we perform the concentrating therefore the Poles carry out the hiking.”
Maria: “It’s is absurd how you take appeal. Once i beginning to give a story, you finish they. If i continue a diet, you eliminate the extra weight. Easily keeps a cool, you cough. While you want to ever before have a baby, I am not so sure I would function as the mother.”
美人になりたい運営事務局
